Where It All Began / Compare the Evidence
THE ORIGIN QUESTION

Where It All Began

Origin Question ranks the leading explanations for how the universe began. We weigh evidence from any source readers can verify and update the leaderboard as new findings come in.

Origins Debate Arena · Homepage

What traces would a vanished civilization leave?

Evidence & Science

Peer-reviewed search

How astronomers check infrared candidates

A face-on artist’s concept comparing the Milky Way and the Bullseye Galaxy

Artist’s comparison of the Milky Way and the Bullseye Galaxy.

NASA, ESA, Ralf Crawford (STScI)

Project Hephaistos screened stars for unusual infrared light. An independent analysis explored how background sources could account for candidate signals.

Angular resolution and the location of the infrared source matter. Follow-up measurements can help separate a star’s own emission from light arriving from another source in the same direction.

The Great Unknown

Published thought experiment

The Silurian hypothesis

Banded rock layers exposed in the Grand Canyon

Exposed layers in the Grand Canyon illustrate how past environments can leave a geological record.

National Park Service

Gavin Schmidt and Adam Frank asked how an industrial society predating humans might be detectable in the geological record.

Long after artifacts degrade or erode, shifts in isotopes, sediment or chemistry might persist. Natural events can leave overlapping signatures. Several independent indicators at the same horizon would make a stronger case.

Related topics