Where It All Began / Model workspace
THE ORIGIN QUESTION

Where It All Began

Origin Question ranks the leading explanations for how the universe began. We weigh evidence from any source readers can verify and update the leaderboard as new findings come in.

Mystery of the Week

Loading this week’s question…

Origins Debate Arena

Compare competing explanations and vote on which question deserves a closer look.

Enter the arena →

Origins Quiz

Three quick questions on pyramids, Mars, and the search for alien civilizations.

Take the quiz →

Universe Origins Leaderboard

Top five theories right now

The Big Bang

The early universe was extremely hot and dense. Space expanded and cooled. The leftover glow and the way galaxies move help us test this picture.

Planck · Cosmological parameters

Space grew incredibly fast

In its first moments, space may have expanded far faster than it does today. That could explain tiny differences in the universe’s oldest light. Physicists still debate what drove it.

Planck · Constraints on inflation

Dark energy might change

The universe’s expansion is speeding up. Some measurements hint that whatever drives that speed-up may change over time. The hint still needs confirmation.

DESI · DR2 cosmological constraints

The universe might have bounced

Imagine an earlier universe shrinking, then expanding again. Some models predict that a bounce like this could start the expansion we see. We have no confirmed sign of one.

Ashtekar & Singh · Loop quantum cosmology

The universe might repeat

What if our universe is one chapter in a repeating story? Some models propose cycle after cycle. We have no confirmed evidence of an earlier cycle.

Steinhardt & Turok · A cyclic model

Top five evolving theories

Could the universe be twice as old?

A published model proposes 26.7 billion years. It makes numerical predictions that can be checked against telescope data. The standard estimate remains about 13.8 billion years.

Rajendra Gupta · Older-universe proposal

Was the universe here before it expanded?

One physics model starts with a universe that stayed nearly the same size before expanding. There’s no confirmed observation of that earlier phase.

Ellis & Maartens · The emergent universe

Could we be inside a black hole?

One physics model proposes that a collapsing black hole in another universe could give rise to ours. There’s no confirmed signal that distinguishes this scenario from other accounts.

Nikodem Popławski · Black-hole model

Are there other universes?

Some models predict separate regions of space, often called bubble universes. The idea has versions with different predictions and no confirmed observation of another universe.

Stanford Encyclopedia · The multiverse

Are we living in a simulation?

What if everything we experience runs on a computer? The original argument is philosophical. The broad idea has no agreed test that would settle it.

Nick Bostrom · Simulation argument

Recent cosmic findings

What telescopes and their teams have observed.

NASA APOD · Webb

Webb traces jets in a stellar nursery

A field of young stars and bright knots embedded in a dusty cloud

Webb’s infrared view of the NGC 7129 stellar nursery.

NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI; Image Processing: A. Pagan (STScI) · License

NASA’s November 16 image feature revisits Webb’s infrared view of NGC 7129. The image shows young stars and knots of glowing material where their jets interact with the cloud, giving astronomers a way to study how newborn stars reshape their surroundings.

Webb · Fast radio bursts

A millisecond flash from the young universe

A field of galaxies with a close-up marking the radio burst location

Webb’s view of the host of FRB 20240304B, with the burst position marked.

NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI, T. Nanayakkara (USYD). Image Processing: J. DePasquale (STScI) · License

Webb located the host galaxy of FRB 20240304B. Its light puts the burst about three billion years after the Big Bang, making it the most distant known fast radio burst at the time of the report. Its host offers clues about the source, whose identity remains uncertain.

Webb · Planet formation

Dust carries clues to planetary collisions

Illustration of two rocky bodies colliding inside a dust ring

Artist’s concept of a collision inside an extreme debris disc.

NASA, ESA, CSA, J. Olmsted (STScI) · License

Webb measured the chemistry of dust around young stars. Some discs had silica-rich material consistent with collisions energetic enough to vaporize rock. Researchers infer the likely size of the colliding bodies from the debris; Webb did not see the impacts themselves.

Unusual ideas, tested

What researchers measured, modeled, or are still trying to test.

Hypothesis tested with spectra

Is a little red dot a black hole wrapped in gas?

An annotated galaxy field with an inset highlighting a tiny red object

The annotated Webb image identifies GLIMPSE-17775 behind the Abell S1063 cluster.

NASA, ESA, CSA, V. Kokorev (University of Texas at Austin), A. Pagan (STScI) · License

Webb’s spectrum of GLIMPSE-17775 supports the idea that a growing supermassive black hole is shrouded in dense gas. This is evidence about one object. Researchers still need to see whether the same explanation fits other little red dots.

Classification tested with two telescopes

A star cluster that didn’t fit the label

Thousands of closely packed stars in a nearly round cluster

Webb and Hubble’s view of Terzan 5.

NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI, G. Zullo (University of Bologna), F. R. Ferraro (University of Bologna). Image Processing: A. Pagan (STScI) · License

Webb and Hubble observations point to as many as four episodes of star formation in Terzan 5. That history supports classifying it as a surviving fragment of the Milky Way’s early bulge and explains why an ordinary globular-cluster label fell short.

Early galaxy models · Spectroscopy

How early could a bright galaxy form?

A wide galaxy field with a magnified inset marking MoM-z14

Webb’s COSMOS field with the distant galaxy MoM-z14 identified.

NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI, R. Naidu (MIT), Image Processing: J. DePasquale (STScI) · License

Webb spectroscopy confirmed that MoM-z14 was already shining about 280 million years after the Big Bang. Its brightness and early appearance give galaxy-formation models a concrete benchmark. The observation does not on its own imply a different age for the universe.

A disputed claim · Two videos

Could you settle the flat-Earth argument with a stick?

Flat-Earth advocate Mark Sargent explains his case in his own words. A NASA scientist takes up the same question using observations people have made for centuries. Try the shadow test, then decide what you’d measure next.

Try the shadow test

On the same date, ask someone well north or south of you to measure a vertical stick’s shadow at their local solar noon. Record the stick height, shadow length, and locations. Earth’s curvature predicts how the angle changes with latitude. Repeat with a third location to give competing explanations another observation to match.

Take the Earth Shape Challenge →Join the discussion →
The full disk of Earth photographed by the Apollo 17 crew

The Blue Marble, photographed from Apollo 17 in 1972.

NASA Johnson Space Center

Play here · NASA · How do we know Earth isn’t flat?
Play here · Mark Sargent · Flat Earth Clues introduction

The Why Files · Hollow Moon

The Moon rang like a bell. What was that about?

Apollo deliberately crashed hardware into the Moon, and the vibrations took a long time to die out. The Why Files follows the story into a wilder idea: an engineered, hollow Moon.

What can a moonquake tell you?

Quake waves travel differently through different materials. Apollo measurements reveal a layered interior. The gradual fading of vibrations tells us about how lunar rock carries and scatters energy.

Join the discussion →
A cratered full view of the near side of the Moon

The Moon’s near side, mapped by the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter.

NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center/Arizona State University

Play here · The Why Files · The Moon Is a Hollow Spaceship

Evidence & Science

The Great Unknown

Disputed claim

Lost technology and the pyramid power-plant claim

A stone pillar fragment resting on a dark floor slab

Stone from Khufu’s pyramid temple at Giza, photographed in a museum.

Museo Egizio (resized and cropped) · License

Play here · Netflix · Ancient Apocalypse trailer

Lost-civilization documentaries ask whether an earlier society passed down sophisticated knowledge. Christopher Dunn’s The Giza Power Plant goes further and assigns the monument a technological purpose.

The trailer presents the broader lost-civilization premise. The radio-wave study addresses a different question about the pyramid’s shape.

The Why Files · Crop circles and cover-up claims

Who made the patterns in the fields?

Giant patterns show up in fields. Some people see art. Others see a message. The Why Files takes the story through alien theories and an alleged cover-up.

What clue would you want before guessing?

Try an unbroken record of the field before, during, and after the pattern formed. In 1991, Doug Bower and Dave Chorley claimed credit for circles and demonstrated their technique. An elaborate pattern can be made by people. Any stronger claim needs evidence from the formation itself.

Join the discussion →
A circular pattern of flattened crops in a field near West Kennett

A crop circle photographed near West Kennett, England.

Chris Gunns / Geograph Britain and Ireland (WebP conversion) · License

Play here · The Why Files · Aliens & Espionage: Crop Circles and the CIA Coverup