Where It All Began / Compare the Evidence
THE ORIGIN QUESTION

Where It All Began

Origin Question ranks the leading explanations for how the universe began. We weigh evidence from any source readers can verify and update the leaderboard as new findings come in.

Origins Debate Arena · Homepage

Was there a universe before expansion?

Evidence & Science

Observed and modeled

What ancient light reveals

Mottled patches of blue and orange in an oval map of the microwave sky

Planck’s full-sky map of the cosmic microwave background.

ESA/Planck Collaboration

Play here · NASA · Planck exposes ancient light

Planck mapped variations in the cosmic microwave background. Their pattern lets researchers estimate the universe’s contents and test the hot Big Bang model.

The microwave background comes from a time when the universe became transparent. Its hot and cold patches preserve clues about earlier conditions. Observations of the light constrain models of earlier epochs indirectly.

The Great Unknown

Theoretical proposal

A contraction followed by a bounce

A graphic tracing the universe from the early Big Bang to the present

An illustrated timeline of cosmic expansion. The proposed bounce concerns an earlier phase.

NASA, ESA, P. Oesch and B. Robertson (University of California, Santa Cruz), and A. Feild (STScI)

Some models explore whether the expansion we see could have followed an earlier period of contraction.

A useful prediction would identify a distinctive signal that survives the bounce and can be separated from patterns produced by other models. Researchers can then compare those predictions with data.

Related topics