The Origin Question / Cosmology tests
Website feedback

The Origin Question

Where did it all begin?

Catch up on astronomy and space science every day. We lead with new evidence about how the universe and life began, and track how it changes the case for leading ideas.

Could the universe be twice as old?

· 100,000,000 Monte Carlo trials

Simulation archive

The proposed 26.7-billion-year universe faces a measurable test. The original version predicts too little stretching of supernova light curves. A 2026 revision with an added correction comes close enough that the same observation cannot settle the question. A flat standard expansion model reaches at most 14.51 billion years inside the observational bounds we tested.

See the follow-up simulation across redshifts

Download the replay script · Download the results

Do supernovae slow down as the older model predicts?

The Dark Energy Survey measured light curves from 1,504 Type Ia supernovae. Its fitted time-stretch relation gives a 95% interval of 1.9740 to 2.0348 at redshift 1, after combining the reported statistical and systematic errors in quadrature. A stretch of 2 means the light curve takes twice as long to unfold as it does in the rest frame.

Predicted stretch compared with the DES interval at redshift 1
PredictionCentral stretchTrials inside DES interval
Standard expansion2.0000100,000,000 (100.00%)
CCC+TL · original stretch1.72560 (0%)
CCC+TL · with 2026 correction1.974144,651,876 (44.65%)

Gupta’s 2023 prescription stretches the signal by the expansion part of the redshift alone. The 2026 preprint also multiplies it by the ratio of the hybrid and parent models’ lookback times. That correction is an empirical prescription. The authors identify deriving the arrival-time stretch from the underlying photon propagation as an open test.

We sampled the published tired-light factor 1.159 ± 0.010 and lookback-time ratio 1.144 ± 0.042, converting the 95% margins to Gaussian standard deviations and treating the errors as independent because we lacked their covariance. The result is an overlap count at one redshift. It does not estimate the probability that either model is true or fit the individual DES light curves.

Can standard expansion reach 26.7 or 27.6 billion years?

We drew today’s expansion rate H₀ uniformly from 20 to 100 km/s/Mpc and the matter fraction Ωₘ uniformly from 0.01 to 0.60. We kept 380,605 draws falling within three reported standard deviations of both DESI DR2 + primordial-abundance estimates from Table V. The separate cuts form a conservative rectangle. We assumed flat space and a cosmological constant, and used the analytic matter-plus-Λ age. Omitting radiation gives a slightly higher age at fixed H₀ and Ωₘ.

Target age ±0.10 Gyr inside the expansion screen
Age testedMatching drawsH₀ needed at the DESI central matter fraction
13.797 Gyr · Planck reference103,43268.47 km/s/Mpc
26.7 Gyr · Gupta’s proposal035.38 km/s/Mpc
27.594 Gyr · exactly twice the reference034.24 km/s/Mpc

Age decreases as either H₀ or the matter fraction increases in this model. Evaluating the lowest allowed values of both gives the 14.51 Gyr ceiling for the entire rectangle. The local SH0ES distance ladder gives H₀ = 73.04 ± 1.04 km/s/Mpc. The DESI rectangle concerns flat ΛCDM. The supernova comparison above tests a prediction of CCC+TL directly.

If it were older, would cosmic silence get harder to explain?

We extended the archive’s illustrative constant-rate model. Detectable events start arriving at cosmic age 4 Gyr and remain in a perfect cumulative record. Each trial shares the same first arrival across all ages. The scenarios are calibrated to expect 0.1, 1, or 5 detectable events by 13.797 Gyr.

Percentage of trials with zero detectable events
Expected events by 13.797 GyrAt 13.797 GyrAt 26.7 GyrAt 27.594 Gyr
0.190.48%79.31%78.59%
136.79%9.86%9.00%
50.67%0.000938%0.000577%

With one expected event by 13.797 Gyr, the exact Poisson model moves from 36.8% silence to 9.0%. Sparse or short-lived signals and incomplete searches can change that conclusion. These scenarios don’t infer how often life evolves or how much of the sky we have adequately searched.

Follow-up simulation across redshifts

The original run checked supernova durations at redshift 1. We took the fixed predictions from the 2026 preprint’s appendix and calculated how far the predicted stretch falls below standard expansion at 16 redshifts from 0.1 to 1.6. We divided the revised stretch by the standard value, giving the hybrid-to-parent lookback-time ratio divided by the factor from tired light. No model parameters were fitted to supernova durations.

We then ran 1,000,000 hypothetical measurements with Gaussian errors to see how often a survey would resolve that shortfall at three standard deviations in the predicted direction. The percentages assume the published central predictions and one independent effective measurement per scenario. The scenarios share simulated noise for comparison. They omit model uncertainty and correlated systematics, so they show the measurement precision to aim for.

Chance of detecting the predicted shortfall at three standard deviations
RedshiftRevised shortfall1.5% measurement error1.0% measurement error0.5% measurement error
1.01.31%1.7%4.5%34.9%
1.21.64%2.8%8.7%61.2%
1.62.37%7.7%26.3%95.8%

The revised model predicts a larger shortfall at higher redshift. The Dark Energy Survey supernova sample reaches about redshift 1.2. The redshift 1.6 result forecasts how a future measurement could distinguish the models. Start with a fit to the individual supernova light curves within the observed range, using independently calibrated data and propagating survey and model uncertainties. Then check whether a higher-redshift sample can reach the precision in the table.

Seed 20261119. Download the follow-up replay script · Download all 16 predictions and simulated results

What could distinguish the models?

One independent study found strong tension between the original CCC+TL fit and galaxy-age estimates of expansion. Gupta showed that adding an empirical correction to the galaxy-age relation greatly reduces that tension. An independent test would derive both corrections from the theory, fix the parameters before looking at new data, and compare predictions across redshift with supernova durations, galaxy ages and the full microwave-background spectrum.

Each Monte Carlo iteration evaluated the expansion screen, the supernova predictions and the paired silence scenarios. Seed 20261118.