The Origin Question / How we verify claims
Website feedback

The Origin Question

Where did it all begin?

Catch up on astronomy and space science every day. We lead with new evidence about how the universe and life began, and track how it changes the case for leading ideas.

Evidence Library

How we verify claims

We trace a claim back to the original measurements, observations, or samples. Then we look at how the evidence was collected, what else might explain it, and whether independent researchers found the same result.

Verifiable evidence

Separate teams or instruments can measure the same thing. Published methods and data give other researchers a way to check the result.

Gravitational waves from a black hole merger

Two LIGO detectors, one in Washington and one in Louisiana, recorded the same signal. Researchers checked for local noise and released the data so others could analyze it.

LIGO’s checks · Public data

A planet orbiting 51 Pegasi

One team measured a repeating wobble in the star’s motion. A second team at Lick Observatory measured the same wobble with its own telescope.

NASA’s account of the confirmation

Not verifiable

A black dog in the foreground and a Bigfoot-like figure among the trees in the background.
The image alone gives us no reliable way to identify the figure. An original file with a documented time and location, separate footage, or physical evidence from the scene would give investigators something to check.